Decades ago, James won Rose’s hand with an unforgettable declaration: “You have too much beauty for this lake to hold. Too much beauty for this night. Too many stars you’re outshining.” Now 75 years old, and in self-imposed confinement since her husband’s death, Rose contemplates the importance of a life’s words when all that remains is quietness of grief. As her daughter Emma and the enigmatic Pastor Hidge attempt to coax Rose from her room, the trio navigates the walls that hide their hearts and embrace memories that will only fade with time. Bittersweet, poignant, and touchingly funny, Too Much, Too Much, Too Many sinks the audience into a world of love too great for words.